I was talking with a writer recently who’d just published her first novel. She’d done everything “right”—set up Amazon ads, joined KDP Select, read all the marketing gurus, tracked her data obsessively. She was spending hours every day tweaking keywords and analyzing click-through rates.
“I’m losing 20 cents on every dollar I spend,” she told me. “But everyone says if I just optimize better, find the right keywords, adjust my bids…”
I stopped her there. Because I’ve been down that exact rabbit hole.
To read more of my posts, subscribe here for free or click to read more about revision, starting your writing practice, writing tips, book coaching
The Marketing Treadmill
Over the course of the last ten years, I’ve thrown myself into the modern book marketing machine from a series of angles. I read David Gaughran. I took Mark Dawson’s courses. I joined Steven Pieper’s Author Marketing Mastery program (and paid the significant fees that came with it).
I set up Facebook ads, Amazon ads, direct sales funnels. I built a Shopify store, integrated BookFunnel for ebook delivery, created email sequences. It was a full Rube Goldberg machine of marketing automation.
I tracked every metric. Cost per click. Conversion rates. Return on ad spend. Kindle Unlimited page reads. I had spreadsheets that would make an accountant weep.
The result? I was spending a dollar to make back 80 cents.
Every month, I’d think: “Next month I’ll crack the code. I’ll find the right audience, the perfect keyword, the optimal bid.” But the math kept coming back the same: I was paying for the privilege of giving my books away.
The Question That Changed Everything
Then my business mentor gave me an answer that stopped me cold:
When I asked him what I’d been wondering: “If these marketing gurus are making so much money selling books through ads, why are they spending so much time selling courses?”
His response was simple. “There’s your answer.”
The real money isn’t in the marketing they’re teaching—it’s in selling the dream of that marketing to authors.
What I Learned from the Success Stories
The few people I met who were actually making money from book marketing fell into two categories:
- Authors with 20+ books who’d been optimizing ads for 8+ years
- Husband-wife teams where one person wrote full-time while the other did marketing full-time
In other words: You need either a massive backlist built over nearly a decade, or you need a full-time marketing department.
Most of us have neither.
The Business Reality Nobody Talks About
Here’s what we also know: Traditional publishing (“The Big 5”) is struggling with these same economics.
It’s no longer the Big 5—Now it’s the Big 4. Borders is closed. Barnes and Noble?
When I worked with Thomas & Mercer (Amazon’s mystery imprint), they had internal advertising advantages that helped me to sell more than 40,000 copies of my first book with them. But then Amazon decided they’d make more money selling that advertising space to outside bidders rather than using it internally.
Suddenly, my second book with them was competing with hundreds of other authors for the same ad space. My in-house promotion got diluted across five other books instead of focusing on mine alone.
If a major publisher backed by Amazon’s own systems can’t make the economics work consistently, what chance do indie authors have?
When I Was Most Fulfilled as a Writer
Looking back over my career, the periods when I felt most successful had nothing to do with sales metrics.
The best period was when I was podcasting my novels. Every week, I’d release chapters as audio, and listeners would email me. They’d tell me which characters they loved, which plot twists surprised them, how my story affected their commute or their workout.
I had direct connection with readers who were actively engaging with my work. The money was secondary—what mattered was that people were actually experiencing the stories I was creating.
The same feeling came from live readings. Standing in front of people, reading my work aloud, seeing their reactions in real-time. Answering questions afterward. Signing books for people who’d driven across town to hear me read.
Those connections felt like why I became a writer in the first place.
The False Choice
Somewhere along the way, we’ve been sold a false choice: Either optimize for maximum sales through digital marketing, or accept that nobody will read your work.
But there’s a third option: Optimize for reader connection instead of sales metrics.
This might mean:
- Serializing your work on Substack to build an engaged audience
- Creating audio versions so people can experience your book while walking or driving
- Doing readings at libraries and bookstores to connect face-to-face with readers
- Offering free digital copies through QR codes at events
- Building genuine relationships with readers who will tell their friends
To read more of my posts, subscribe here for free or click to read more about revision, starting your writing practice, writing tips, book coaching
What This Looks Like in Practice
Instead of spending hours tweaking Amazon ad keywords, what if you:
Created a Substack newsletter where you serialized your novel? Include both text and audio versions. Build an audience of people who actively wait for your next chapter.
Reached out to local libraries to offer author readings? Librarians are readers, and libraries have email lists full of people looking for their next book.
Set up a simple way for people to get your book for free? At live events, at the end of blog posts, through social media. Remove the friction between interest and access.
Followed your creative energy? When I mentioned video adaptations to that writer I was coaching, her whole face lit up. She went from looking exhausted by spreadsheets to excited about storytelling. That energy matters more than any conversion rate.
The Hard Truth About Amazon Ads
Here’s what I learned after a year of serious effort with Amazon advertising:
Most people who make it work have been at it for close to a decade, testing and optimizing constantly. They treat book marketing as a second full-time job. They have extensive backlists that create compounding returns.
And even then, many of them are still just breaking even.
The platforms benefit more than the authors do. Amazon makes money whether your ads work or not. The course creators make money whether your ads work or not.
But you? You’re spending your writing time managing spreadsheets instead of creating the next story.
What Actually Drives Book Sales
Word of mouth. Always has, always will.
When someone reads your book and tells three friends about it, that’s worth more than a thousand targeted ads. When a librarian recommends your book to patrons, that creates readers who actually finish what they start.
When you read a chapter aloud and someone in the audience thinks, “I need to know what happens next,” you’ve created genuine demand that no algorithm can replicate.
The question isn’t how to optimize your ads. The question is how to create work that people want to recommend to others.
My New Optimization Strategy
I’m done optimizing for metrics I can’t control. Instead, I’m optimizing for:
Direct reader feedback. I want to hear from people who’ve read my work and been affected by it.
Creative fulfillment. I want to spend my time writing stories, not managing ad campaigns.
Sustainable practices. I want a writing career that energizes me rather than drains me.
Human connection. I want to remember why I started writing in the first place—to tell stories that matter to real people.
The Path Forward
This doesn’t mean giving up on reaching readers. It means choosing methods that align with why you became a writer.
If you love performing, do readings. If you enjoy online community, build a newsletter. If you’re excited about multimedia, create video content or podcasts. If you thrive on face-to-face interaction, focus on local events.
Follow your energy instead of fighting against it.
The writer I was coaching lit up when we talked about creative approaches to sharing her work. She’d been grinding through Amazon ads because that’s what she thought she was “supposed” to do. But her excitement was infectious when she talked about other possibilities.
That excitement—that creative energy—is worth more than any sales funnel.
The Real Metrics That Matter
At the end of the day, here are the numbers I care about:
- How many people finish reading my book?
- How many reach out to tell me how it affected them?
- How many recommend it to friends?
- How often do I feel energized by my writing work rather than drained by it?
These metrics can’t be tracked in a spreadsheet. But they’re the ones that determine whether you have a sustainable, fulfilling writing practice or just an expensive hobby that makes you miserable.
Permission to Stop
If you’re exhausted by the marketing treadmill, you have permission to stop.
You have permission to optimize for reader connection instead of conversion rates. You have permission to choose fulfillment over spreadsheet optimization. You have permission to remember that you became a writer to tell stories, not to become a digital marketer.
The publishing industry wants to convince you that their metrics are the only ones that matter. But the most successful authors I know—the ones with sustainable, decades-long careers—prioritize reader relationships over algorithmic optimization.
Stop chasing the metrics that drain your creative energy. Start building the connections that fuel it.
Your readers are waiting for your stories, not your perfectly optimized ad campaigns.
Ready to focus on the writing instead of the marketing? Building a sustainable writing practice means knowing which battles are worth fighting. Schedule a consultation to discuss strategies that align with your creative goals, or join my newsletter for practical advice on building a writing career that actually energizes you.
